Which Roof is More Cost-Effective Metal or Shingles?

Posted by Carolyn Lynch on June 26th, 2023

Whether you’re replacing your existing roof or installing a new one from scratch, the material you choose for your new roof will have a significant impact on how your home will look and feel for years to come. 

When it comes to the cost of roofing materials, people often compare the cost of metal and asphalt roofs before deciding on the best option for their homes. In this article, our experts will provide you with a comprehensive analysis, including numerical data, to help you determine the right material for your roof.

Before drawing any conclusions about cost-effectiveness, make sure you understand the per-square-foot expenses associated with each material. Additionally, we must consider a range of factors that may influence the final decision-making process.

Metal Roof Cost

In general, the cost of metal roofing is determined by measuring the material. This means you will be charged based on the square footage of your roofing system. For instance, the average roof area for a home in the U.S. is approximately 1700 square feet. So, if you are planning to install a low-pitched roof, you’ll need to allocate 00 or more for high-quality roofing materials. 

Although this may initially seem like a huge expense, remember that you are making a long-term investment in the protection of your roof. Moreover, metal roofs are virtually maintenance-free. So, you won’t have to spend much time, money, and effort on its care and maintenance for years to come.

Another major benefit of metal roofing is its remarkable durability, which allows it to withstand even the harshest of weather conditions with aplomb.

Asphalt Roof Cost

Asphalt shingles are among the most widely available and cost-effective roofing options on the market. In fact, over 66% of homes in the U.S. utilize asphalt shingles due to their affordability and accessibility.

An asphalt roof typically offers a lifespan of approximately between 20 and 30 years, which is quite satisfactory. However, regular maintenance is necessary to ensure its longevity. However, even with proper maintenance, asphalt shingles may develop some forms of damage due to general wear and tear. In such cases, you may need shingle replacement.

When it comes to the installation cost of these shingles, you can expect it to range between 00 and 00 on average. Several factors can influence the overall cost, including the pitch of your roof, the size of the area to be covered, and the quality of the shingles you choose. 

Asphalt Shingles vs. Metal Roof: Factors to Consider

1. Pitch of the Roof

When it comes to the cost of installing roofing materials, the pitch of your roof plays a vital role. For optimal performance, metal roofing is usually recommended for pitches of 3/12. However, if you have a steeper roof and prefer asphalt shingles, remember that their installation requires the expertise of experienced roofing specialists for the best results. Furthermore, roofs with steeper slopes generally come at a higher installation cost.

2. Roofing Material Quality

The quality of roofing material is often reflected in its cost. Additionally, a good sign of a roof's longevity is the warranty provided. Opting for warranties that extend over 50 years is often a strong indication that the product is built to withstand the test of time. By choosing a high-quality roofing material backed by an extensive warranty, you can ensure that you have invested in a roofing solution that offers exceptional quality and peace of mind.

3. Local Climate

Metal roofing performs exceptionally well in adverse weather conditions, such as strong winds, due to its durability. Additionally, it facilitates the quick flow of water off your roof, which is beneficial in all climates. If you live in an area with a predominantly cold climate, metal shingles are a great option for you.

Asphalt roofing shingles, on the other hand, offer a versatile choice that can adapt to both cold and warm climates due to their well-rounded design. However, asphalt shingles may be prone to damage during high winds that exceed 120 miles per hour.

The Bottom-line: 

At the end of the day, the choice between metal roofing and asphalt roofing largely depends on the above factors as well as your budget. Asphalt shingles are often the most cost-effective option available on the market, making them an attractive choice for homeowners on a budget. 

However, if you want to make a long-term investment in the durability and longevity of your roof, a metal roof installation is a much better option. 

Call Louisiana Roof Crafters at 985-238-4575 for more information. We service areas in Baton Rouge, Denham Springs, Hammond, Covington, Mandeville, Slidell, and New Orleans, LA.